Kenya-Uganda Railway Concessionaire; A Case of Two Bungling Governments - Instablogs
Kenya-Uganda Railway Concessionaire; A Case of Two Bungling Governments
Harun Lumiti , Mombasa: Aug 20 2008
Made Popular Aug 21 2008
Kenya :

Kenya-Uganda Railway Concessionaire; A Case of Two Bungling Governments
More than a century after construction of the Kenya-Uganda railway line by the British colonial government and almost half a century after the two nations attained their independence, the East African governments are yet to demonstrate a capacity to manage a modern railway service.

If utterances by leaders in both countries are anything to go by, they actually find the Kenya-Uganda railway to be a source of wry humor and rhetoric at any and every forum that provides them with a microphone. President Museveni referred to it as “our antiquated system fit for the museums” during the Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting in Kampala last year. The ‘diplomatic’ laughter that followed the presidential jest paled in comparison to the guffaws that erupted at State-House Nairobi a few months later when he repeated the same line at the inauguration of Kenya’s coalition government. Here, I think the mirthful but uneasy VIPs were probably just attempting to exorcise their guilt as the guardians who supported railway vandals during the electioneering hooliganism.

Kenya’s Prime Minister Raila Odinga also never tires to remind his audiences that ever since the colonial government completed laying down the railway line, successive governments “have not added an inch to the line”. And he says it with such a wide grin plastered on his face that one can almost be sure that he finds it more hilarious than distressing. Massaged by the decibel levels of his cheering squads, it still hasn’t occurred to the man that the onus is now on him to build competent capacities.

So other than making lofty vision statements and poking fun at the Africans’ profound lack of skill, these men and women in government are just floating along, eating, sleeping and waiting for Godot.

Not only has the line suffered disrepair and unrelenting vandalism but services have degenerated and almost ground to a halt; a precarious position that is causing extensive harm to regional trade. With the decades long ineptness of the two governments to manage the railway services, the business community in the region has over the years been lobbying for privatization or partnership arrangements to operate the railway line. Two years ago, the governments acquiesced and jointly advertised a tender for an operator before granting a concessionary contract to the Rift Valley Railways. It is now clear that the decision to award the contract to RVR was a colossal blunder that has seen the railway operator hurtling downhill, shunting from one crisis to another right from day one.

The initial partners in the initial RVR consortium now feel vindicated after spending two years in courts crying foul play on the part of Sheltam Pty. They seem to have successfully managed to buy extra time from the two governments by cobbling up a resuscitation plan for the concession agreement. Support for the plan from the wary international lenders seem to have convinced the two governments to move along with the plan and give RVR another three months to clean up their act or surrender the concession.

There is widespread exasperation amongst the citizenry in the region who cannot stomach this inexplicable impotence on the part of their governments even as devious characters plunder national assets. It is unconvincing for them to claim that their hands are tied by ‘contractual obligations’ when it is clear that the same was entered into through false representations by Sheltam. That they have opted to extend this commercial tomfoolery gives credence to muted suggestions that senior officials in government are in fact knee-deep in a monumental con. The alternative conclusion would be that the people managing our infrastructure are grossly incompetent and clueless-in-wonderland as rings are woven around them by expatriate weasels. A conclusion that is indeed hard to swallow when one considers the array of professionals that were involved in crafting the deal.

Members of Parliament in both countries, having slept on the job as the railway was being handed over, are now throwing up belated tantrums demanding explanations from their governments and punitive action against those behind the debacle. It is now that the pretentious legislators are purporting to adduce evidence that in actual fact, no due diligence was performed on RVR prior to being awarded the contract. The problem with this pompous noise making is that, other than serve for cloak-and-dagger entertainment in Parliament, it does little to undo the extensive damage on citizens’ livelihoods or compensate for losses occasioned on commerce and trade.

This fiasco goes to confirm my long held opinion that our politicians are by far the greatest impediment to the development of the region. And in this case, they are quickly running out of excuses for their inability to manage the railway system. I expect that the next stunt will be for the railway management to walk out of their offices with underpants drawn over their heads and pencils stuck up their noses. Their very well paid lawyers can then, in mitigation on their behalf, plead ‘mismanagement due to insanity’. Insanity induced by the Lunatic Line!

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
Sorry no picture found for this combination of tags. Try to search minimum number of tags at once
1 Stars
Milind
Thiruvananthapuram, India
Extremely well written and the dry humour was not missed in your post. The problem with the erstwhile colonies of European countries that are still lagging behind is that they have not been able to build up on the base of infrastructure that the colonial masters laid. Railways is a prime example of this. It is the basic infrastructure that goes a long way towards making a country prosperous. Some countries like India has developed the railway network to the extent that railways have become the backbone of our countries progress.
1 Stars
Many thanks Milind.

Indeed many of us in these parts are dismayed by the levels of greed and corruption exhibited by our infrastructure managers. Otherwise, we do have some very skilled professionals who should be able to advance our economies. If only they can serve the right spirit.

You’d be surprised the kind of shady spirits that drive even our presidents. For instance, our first president is on record as having rebuked one of his co-freedom fighters for lagging behind in amassing wealth. He is also reported to have ’cautioned’ his allies to steal wisely because he would not defend them if they got caught.

President number two advised his men to ”milk the cow with a cup, not a bucket”.

President number three defended his crony who had been caught dipping his fingers in the till thus; ”whose goat has he eaten?”

The frame of minds at the top has just never been right for progress.
1 Stars
Sonu
Thiruvananthapuram, India
It is indeed such a shame that politicians would indulge in crude jokes and try to hide their inefficiency. How can a country make any progress if basic infrastructure building like railway lines and roads is neglected in such a way? Isn't there any rail transport ministry/department in Kenya? If there is what are they doing?
1 Stars
Hi Sonu,

Yes we do have a whole Ministry of Transport. And guess what, many Kenyans are presently asking the same question, ”what is the Ministry doing?”

The current Minister has himself recently declared that he is a qualified ”Transport Scientist”, whatever that is. Not many people are sure where he spends his waken hours but he occasionally shows up to remind us that ”it is not my responsibility to implement policy”. Whether he even knows the ’policy’ is increasingly becoming questionable.

Suffice it to say that effectiveness of Ministries is, unfortunately, largely dependent on the personal drive of the Minister in charge. And the current head is as colorless as they come. And narrow minded too. He is, for instance, of the view that the Port of Mombasa which falls under his docket can only be managed by his tribesman.

He is the classic example of the successive incompetents that have continued to reign supreme at the Ministry.
1 Stars
Tiaan
Pretoria, South Africa
As in many African countries the government of Kenya is a corrupt lot. It is embarrassing to see them making lame excuses for their failure to do anything about the abysmal railway system in Kenya. Why don't the people of Kenya push the government for sweeping reforms in this sector? Public pressure might change the way the Kenyan government works. Though not a model and has many shortcomings, the Kenyans can take a leaf out of the South African railway system.
1 Stars
I agree with you Tiaan, the corruption is so extensive and is probably even crippling the public watchdogs that should be safeguarding public interests.Even with the atrociously high salaries for members of these anti-corruption bodies, it is now becoming clear that they are in fact getting in bed with the very devils they should be ferreting out. This coziness between our watchmen and thieves is frustrating and takes the wind out of public pressure for reforms. But thanks to the internet, citizens’ anti-corruption enlightenment continues.

Right now Tiaan, Kenyans might be very hesitant to take a leaf from the South African railway system. Our government borrowed one such ’leaf’ in the name of one Roy Puffet of Sheltam Railways Pty. He was contracted to run the railway here for 25 years, but 25 months after winning the contract everyone is wondering what voodoo the fellow was planning to engage to accomplish the feat. He has been given marching orders and is leaving behind the railway worse than he found it. His brief sortie into Kenya with criminal intent was, of course, only possible due to the cross-country corruption networks.

Many Kenyans, however, appreciate South Africa as a worthy competitor in commerce and trade and they generally agree that systems their do work much better. Indeed many Kenyans continue to take up opportunities in South Africa. Our government is simply lagging behind in exploiting such mutually beneficial arrangements and when they wake up to emulate their citizens, they go searching in shadowy corners.
1 Stars
Freestyler
Stockholm, Sweden
When I read your post and the comments I couldn't believe that the leaders of a country can be so insensitive to crack jokes and pass remarks like ”milk the cow with a cup, not a bucket”. This kind of a remark even if made in humour would mean the end of his political career in my country.
1 Stars
Hi Freestyler,

It may be shocking but its true. Our political set up pretends to be democratic and to be guided by values such us honesty and pride in public service. In actual fact, it is still suffering the traditional African patriarchal stranglehold and is just beginning to learn that the Big Man can be held to account for their actions and utterances. But the learning is painfully slow as it is undermined by the supposedly ’learned’ class who quickly abandon their vanguard roles once they taste the joys of ’power’.

This ’learned’ lot are of great disservice to our growth especially when they bandy about ’facts’ acquired in their little education. Such as reminding us that because the West took a few hundred years to develop their democracies, we should not be rushed. Of course they don’t mind rushing to surpass the parliamentary salaries of the West!
1 Stars
Rose Ng'ang'a
Nairobi, Kenya
What a nice piece to read, but since time in memorial our politicians have prooved ham-fisted to deal with any national issue,all what they care about is who gets what in the government circles, what they proudly brand as ’national balance’ and all they do whenever a chance is given is amass wealth through any nick and cranny.
1 Stars
You’re right Rose, our politicians do not seem to subscribe to any values that would help them render meaningful public service. They are in office for self, self and self and demand that the public serves them rather than the other way round.

We have quite some distance to cover in turning around this decadent mentality about public service. At some point, the ’vijana tugutuke’ project seemed to be making headway in that direction but seems to have floundered, if the election fiasco is anything to go by. One hopes the youthful folks involved will dust themselves and trudge on. We cannot afford to abandon the journey.
Add your Comment